Review Results Are In! - This is What You've All Been Waiting For

You can scroll down this page to find the 'Winners' list, but you would be better advised to read through the preliminary information first. There is a lot to learn on this page which will help you understand the entire review grading process.

To date I have reviewed the ingredients of over 1,250 canned cat foods. You can get an excellent snapshot of the overall industry performance by looking at the product grade percentages below.

A - 0.16% (2)
B - 2.5% (32)
C - 5.8% (73)
D - 5.8% (74)
E - 13.3% (167)
X - 72.4% (907)

D + E + X = a gigantic 91.5% substandard quality cat food. The industry as a whole should be ashamed of itself.

Below is my list of ‘better-than-average’ cat food brands. Keep in mind that I consider 91.5% of wet cat foods to be substandard (D+E+X). This is like picking the less damaged apples out of a trash can full of damaged apples. There are some, however, which are better than others.

Notice that I don’t just award a grade to any particular manufacturer overall. I choose particular products within a product line. Be careful - You may have an (X)-rejected ‘flavor’ within the same product line designated with others designated as (B)s. Don’t take it for granted that all of a particular manufacture’s products are good. Don't generalize that 'XYZ' cat food is all good.

Also notice that some of these products may have less-than-desired individual ingredients. You have to remember what kind of industry we are dealing with here. Out of a sea of bad products, one has to accept substandard ingredients some of the time. For example, some of the products below contain sodium selenite, which is bad if overdosed.

Be clear that I’m not recommending these cat foods. I’m just showing you which foods’ ingredients were better than others. Hopefully, you will review each product and make a choice for yourself.

Remember... there is no way to determine QUALITY from the label or ingredients list

Always keep this fact in mind - - there is no way to determine dietary quality from reading either the product's label or the ingredient list. Although a product may, on first glance, contain great ingredients, there is no way to determine how those ingredients were sourced. Is the manufacturer using diseased animal material and material sourced from non-slaughtered animals, i.e., euthanized, and/or drowned, and/or decomposing livestock, and/or animals commonly referred to as ‘road kill’ (allowed by the FDA)?

Important Notes Before We Go Any Further

I have chosen the products below based solely on their ingredients list content. While the ingredients list is valuable because you can readily recognize substandard ingredients, it is also true that there is no way to determine the quality or the source of any of the ingredients.

Also... I do not pretend to know, or be aware of, or understand any of these companies' past history, past recall history, or anything else about them. Some of these companies have histories which have significantly damaged their reputations, and that damage continues to haunt them to this day. Hopefully, they have turned the corner and are now producing better quality products in better quality containers. Should I find out otherwise, I will remove them from the list promptly. Additionally, past performance regarding dog food is not necessarily representative of that with cat food, although one can certainly make the argument that both come out of the same factory.

The astute reader may notice that the products in the following lists have recently been rearranged and reorganized. I felt the adjustment was needed to reflect my studies regarding seafood. As expressed elsewhere on this website, because of it's natural propensity for contamination, fish/seafood should not be used as a primary daily food. Feeding your cat(s) fish often/regularly is not a good idea. Read more about that subject here.

Here's another thought for you... Once you have found your 'ideal' cat food, you still need to vary your cat's diet. It is probably best to mimic cats in the wild who are unlikely to eat the same thing meal after meal after meal. "Interestingly, being exposed to a single protein over the long term makes your cat more likely to develop an allergy to it." - Emily Parker - Catological.com (Doug's note: Although I consider Emily's work essential to the 'cat conversation,' I do not necessarily agree with her cat food reviews.)

Repeat Reminder: Individual products listed below do not mean that the entire brand is acceptable. In some instances the same company that produces a product rated (B) will also produce another one rated (X). Don’t take it for granted that all of a particular manufacturer’s products are good.

Finally, after reading the products lists below, it is so vitally important that you closely read my page regarding Transitioning to New Food. Transitioning is a process which requires care and attention.

As Fed Basis & Dry Matter Basis

The percentages associated with each product below are Dry Matter Basis, which is calculated from As Fed Basis. The As Fed Basis is what you see on the can's label. The Dry Matter Basis excludes the can's moisture content, and reflects the balance expressed as a percentage of all the dry matter alone. Dry Matter Basis is the only way you can accurately compare two products side-by-side. It is also the only way you can compare wet food to dry food. One must convert both wet and dry to Dry Matter Basis before you can compare them. You can read about these calculations on the PawDiet website here.

In the percentages beside each product below, I have left out the percentage for 'fiber.' I did so only because I did not have room on the line for it. I was restricted by the length of the line in the website builder. So... 50.0% 31.8% 11.4% refers to 50.0% Protein, 31.8% Fat, and 11.4% Approximate Carbs. If the three percentages below don't add up to 100% it is because the percentage for Fiber is missing. Said another way, if you want to know the percentage of Fiber, subtract the other three percentages from 100.

Also note, for the purposes here, I did not include the percentages of ash.

The important thing to keep in mind is that the original As Fed Basis figures are supplied by the manufacturer, and as such, are questionable at best. After all... look at the integrity level we are working with here.

I want a diet for my cats that is reflective of their ancestral diet, a diet of cats in the wild

Be clear about one thing... After years of study, I am a proponent of feeding cats raw, bone-in food. I do not believe any canned foods are very good. You may, however, because of price or convenience, need to feed your cat something less than raw, bone-in food. There's one thing for sure... the canned foods below are CERTAINLY better than feeding dry food.

The following cat food list choices are based on current studies regarding the diets of feral cats and cats in the wild. Multiple studies show that the most common food source of these cats is rabbit (41.5%). The other 58.5% of food sources are primarily rodents, birds and insects.

Since no cat food manufacturer has produced a cat food based on rodents, birds and insects, a big part of a wild cat’s diet must be ignored in the search for a currently available commercial cat food. In other words, since I can’t go to the pet store and purchase 'Mice & Birds Brand' cat food, I’m ignoring the other 58% for now.

I am therefore basing my cat food choices as follows PLUS an evaluation of each product's ingredients.

Since domestic cats have been fed and are accustomed to eating to other foods, without supporting scientific data, I assign the following percentages to major food groups.

85% - from herbivore/ungulate animals (beef. sheep/lamb, goat, rabbit, venison, elk, bison, caribou, llama, alpaca, moose)
10 % - poultry (predominately quail, duck, pheasant and a lesser amount of turkey, chicken)
5% - seafood (but only occasionally) See the section on fish here.
0% - pork
0% - dairy (milk / cheese / yogurt, etc) (allergies and intolerance)

85% - 95% of your cat's diet should come from herbivore/ungulate animals:

Primary Daily Feeding Choices:

68.2% 27.3% 4.5% B Tiki Cat / After Dark Paté - Rabbit & Chicken Liver
56.5% 13.0% 4.3% B Tiki Cat / After Dark Paté - Venison & Beef Liver
54.5% 36.4% 04.5% B Hound & Gatos - Lamb & Liver Chewy
50.0% 31.8% 11.4% B RAWZ / 96% Meat - Rabbit Paté Company
50.0% 31.8% 13.6% B Hound & Gatos - Rabbit Formula Chewy
45.8% 33.3.8% 4.2% B Tiki Cat / After Dark Paté - Beef & Beef Liver
45.5% 36.4% 13.6% B Hound & Gatos - Beef Formula Chewy
43.2% 38.6% 13.6% B Canada Fresh - Red Meat Chewy
47.7% 27.3% 20.5% C RAWZ / 96% Meat - Beef & Beef Liver Company

Intermittent, Supplemental, Occasional Feeding Choices:

40.0% 32.0% 22.0% C Wysong - Beef Formula Chewy
40.0% 32.0% 22.0% C Wysong - Rabbit Formula Chewy
44.5% 22.7% 25.0% C *Evanger's - Rabbit Chewy

* I have reservations about including products from Evanger's because of their history of questionable practices. I include this one product only because there aren't many products containing rabbit available in the marketplace. There are 18 other products containing rabbit, but they are all substandard.

Don't make the mistake of comparing the percentages for Primary Daily Feeding Choices to the percentages for Intermittent, Supplemental, Occasional Feeding Choices. You can only reliably compare products within each group. You may also notice percentages which are higher in a product graded 'C' vs. one graded 'B'. For example, although a 'C' has more protein than a 'B', the 'C' may have other questionable ingredients.

5% - 10% of your cat's diet can come from poultry:

(Obviously some items below are poultry + another major food category. However, poultry is the primary ingredient.)

Primary Daily Feeding Choices:

70.5% 10.5.8% 3.7% B Tiki Cat / After Dark - Chicken & Beef Chewy
72.2% 12.8% 3.3% B Tiki Cat / After Dark - Chicken & Lamb Chewy
70.6% 12.9% 4.1% B Tiki Cat / After Dark - Chicken Chewy
72.2% 11.1% 3.9% B Tiki Cat / After Dark - Chicken & Duck Chewy
66.7% 13.3% 3.9% B Tiki Cat / After Dark - Chick. & Quail Egg Chewy
47.7% 38.6% 09.1% B Hound & Gatos - Gamebird Poultry Chewy
45.5% 40.9% 09.1% B Hound & Gatos - Chicken & Ch. Liver Chewy
45.5% 40.9% 09.1% B Hound & Gatos - Duck & Duck Liver Chewy
45.5% 36.4% 11.4% B Hound & Gatos - Turkey & Turkey Liver Chewy
45.5% 31.8% 18.2% B *Essence - Air & Gamefowl Company
43.5% 343.8% 04.3% B Tiki Cat / After Dark Paté - Duck & Chicken Liver
81.0% 13.8% 05.2% C Tiki Cat - Chicken with Egg in Ch. Con. Chewy
80.0% 13.0% 07.0% C Tiki Cat - Suc. Chicken in Chicken Con. Chewy
54.5% 43.2% 02.3% C RAWZ / 96% Meat - Turk. & Tk Liver Company
50.0% 40.9% 04.5% C RAWZ / 96% Meat - Chick & Ch. Liver Company
50.0% 31.8% 11.4% C RAWZ / 96% Meat - Duck & Dk. Liver Company

Intermittent, Supplemental, Occasional Feeding Choices:

85.0% 01.5% 08.5% B Almo Nature / Natural - Chicken B in Br Chewy
84.6% 07.7% 03.8% B PureBites - Chicken Breast in Water Chewy
80.0% 15.0% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Natural - Chick Drm in Br Chewy
90.0% 04.5% 00.0% C Almo Nature / Natural - Chicken & Lv Chewy
85.0% 01.5% 00.0% C Almo Nature / Natural - Chicken & Sh Chewy
76.9% 03.8% 15.4% C PureBites - Chicken Br & Shrimp in W Chewy
40.0% 32.0% 22.0% C Wysong - Chicken Formula Chewy
40.0% 32.0% 22.0% C Wysong - Duck Formula Chewy
40.0% 32.0% 22.0% C Wysong - Turkey Formula Chewy

5% or less of your cat's diet should come from seafood:

(Obviously some items below are seafood + another major food category. However, seafood is the primary ingredient.)

(Some of the foods in this list are more than 'single or individual foods, i.e. they contain other ingredients. They are included as intermittent, supplemental, occasional feeding choices because they contain fish.)

Intermittent, Supplemental, Occasional Feeding Choices:

These products are true I,S,O feeding choices. They don't contain other added ingredients You really can't compare the percentages in the two groups. Only compare within a group.
92.4% 01.8% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Natural - Tuna & Shrimp Chewy
88.2% 00.6% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Natural - Tuna Atlantic Chewy
88.2% 02.9% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Natural - Mackerel in Br Chewy
86.7% 06.7% 00.0% B PureBites - Tuna & Salmon in Water Chewy
85.0% 02.0% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Natural - Tuna Pacific Chewy
85.0% 02.5% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Natural - Tuna & Whiteb Chewy
83.3% 02.8% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Natural - Ocean Fish in B Chewy
79.1% 04.7% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Daily - Tuna in Broth Chewy
79.1% 04.7% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Daily - Tuna with Mack Chewy
79.1% 04.7% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Daily - Tuna with Salm Chewy
79.1% 04.7% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Daily - Tuna with Shrimp Chewy
75.0% 04.5% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Natural - Salmon in Br Chewy
69.2% 07.7% 00.0% B PureBites - Tuna in Water Chewy
65.0% 15.0% 00.0% B Almo Nature / Natural - Trout & Tuna Chewy
93.5% 00.6% 00.0% C Almo Nature / Natural - Tuna & Chicken Chewy
91.7% 04.2% 00.0% C PureBites - Tuna & Chicken in Water Chewy
79.5% 04.5% 00.0% C Almo Nature / Natural - Salmon & Chick Chewy
79.1% 04.7% 00.0% C Almo Nature / Daily - Tuna with Chick Chewy
40.0% 28.0% 00.0% C Wysong - Salmon Formula Chewy

These products do contain other ingredients, but are listed as I,S,O because the main ingredient is seafood. You really can't compare the percentages in the two groups. Only compare within a group.
50.0% 50.0% 00.0% B Hound & Gatos - Salmon, Mack, Sardi Chewy
47.7% 47.7% 00.0% B Hound & Gatos - Salmon Formula Chewy
47.7% 31.8% 15.0% B *Essence - Ocean & Freshwater Company
40.9% 29.5% 25.0% B Vintage - Moist Harbour (not available in the U.S.) Company
68.4% 23.7% 07.9% C Tiki Cat - Tilapia in Tilapia Consomme Chewy

*pate texture/consistency/density good for kittens.

In the end we need a little humor...

Finally, I guess all of this in-depth ingredient analysis can itself be viewed with skepticism. Maybe the most important questions are... How does your pet respond to the food? Does your cat turn up his/her nose and turn around and run away from the dish? (My cat Bubby expresses himself very clearly when he doesn't like a particular food. He begins pawing... as if trying to cover up the nasty, unpleasant, objectionable stuff... just like he would cover his poop in the litter box. LOL)

Cats in the wild, and feral cats, usually eat a diet of rabbits, mice & rats, birds, reptiles/amphibians, small mammals and insects. You Know... Not one of the 1,200 cat food cans I have reviewed contain any of those ingredients (except for rabbit). Imagine going in a pet food store and asking for 'Mice & Birds' cat food. LOL Ignoring reality because society may find it unpleasant is just another example of marketing shaping our lives.

Love to you and your cat(s). - Doug Hines

CatFoodIngredients.com

CatFoodIngredients.com

Review Results Are In! - This is What You've All Been Waiting For

Remember... there is no way to determine QUALITY from the label or ingredients list

Important Notes Before We Go Any Further

Chewy

As Fed Basis & Dry Matter Basis

My Cat Food Recommendations

I want a diet for my cats that is reflective of their ancestral diet, a diet of cats in the wild

Below are the 'better-than-average’ canned cat foods available today (in my opinion)

85% - 95% of your cat's diet should come from herbivore/ungulate animals:

5% - 10% of your cat's diet can come from poultry:

5% or less of your cat's diet should come from seafood:

In the end we need a little humor...

Nothing Else Matters...